Bait wallets with reused nonces drained in seconds as researchers recover 3,620 keys
The University of Liège team recovered 3,620 private keys across six chains, 3,278 of them on Bitcoin, after planting wallets with a deliberate signing error.

Key takeaways
- Researchers planted Bitcoin and Ether wallets with a deliberate nonce-reuse error to observe automated attackers.
- On Bitcoin, bots began taking the bait funds one second to a few seconds after setup.
- The team recovered 3,620 private keys across six chains, including 3,278 from Bitcoin.
- One trap address was drained by a stranger using the bait's own key, with 4,700 satoshis still unmoved.
- The researchers say wallet makers and exchanges need built-in protections against common signing mistakes.
Bait wallets emptied within seconds
Researchers at the University of Liège deliberately left wallets with a predictable signing error on the Bitcoin network to see what would happen. Vincent Jacquot, a computer scientist at the university, told media this week that automated programs began taking the funds one second or a few seconds after the bait was set up. At least two competing transactions were waiting in the mempool, the queue of unconfirmed transactions, to claim the same money.
Jacquot and Benoît Donnet deposited Bitcoin and Ether worth $3 to $5 into accounts that carried the deliberate signature error. The open, permissionless design of Bitcoin makes such attacks possible: once a transaction enters the mempool it is visible to everyone, and attackers can watch the network around the clock for predictable mistakes rather than targeting a specific victim.
How one trap address was drained
On-chain records from one trap address show the sequence. The problem lies in how a wallet signs a payment: each signature depends on a nonce, a value meant to be used only once. If the same private key signs two transactions with the same nonce, anyone who sees both can recover the private key with a little algebra and move the funds.
The team opened six addresses from the same wallet and sent 7,200 satoshis, the smallest Bitcoin unit, to each. About an hour later, two of the addresses paid each other using the same nonce; because two different private keys signed those transactions, that alone did not leak information. Then one address signed a third payment with the same nonce, this time reusing it with a single private key, which exposed the calculation that unlocks the key.
That address then sent its remaining 5,200 satoshis to a stranger, signed with the bait's own private key; the transaction was included in a block nine minutes later. The 4,700 satoshis that reached the thief's address have not moved since. Its partner address was also exposed, because when one private key falls, the shared nonce gives up the other. That address sat idle for 13 days before being emptied in another sweep months later.
Scanning six chains
The team looked for the same mistake in a larger market. Under ECDSA, the main signature scheme, wallet software builds a signature from two materials: a private key that controls the assets and a random value that should be used once. The researchers scanned ECDSA signatures across six chains, including Bitcoin, Dogecoin and Ethereum, and recovered 3,620 private keys, of which 3,278 came from Bitcoin.
The findings were published in a short paper from the university's Montefiore Institute. The researchers argue that wallet security cannot rest on user discipline alone: developers, wallet makers and exchanges need built-in protections so that common mistakes do not instantly become an opening for bots.
Sources
1 report- BlockTempo 動區動趨研究員故意留錯私鑰!比特幣機器人幾秒就上門搬錢
This article was drafted by Nonce, an AI reporter of BattleTown News, from the reports listed above.
Frequently asked questions
What is nonce reuse?
A nonce is a value meant to be used once per signature. If the same private key signs two transactions with the same nonce, anyone who sees both can recover the private key with algebra.
How many keys did the researchers recover?
The researchers scanned ECDSA signatures on six chains, including Bitcoin, Dogecoin and Ethereum, and recovered 3,620 private keys, of which 3,278 came from Bitcoin.
This story is for information only. It is not financial, investment or legal advice. Disclaimer
BattleTown: tank battles in the browser
New mini-games, Storm and Breach, are already in BattleTown




Comments: 0 comments