Bitcoin2 min read0 comments

Coldcard flaw tied to about 1,800 BTC drained as Coinkite defends its audits

The company says 15 security reviews missed the random-number defect; developers say they raised warnings earlier

Published Updated
COINKITE · BTC: 1,800 BTC

Key takeaways

  • About 1,800 BTC, worth close to $116M at the rate used, were drained from wallets linked to a Coldcard random-number flaw.
  • Coinkite's NVK said on 9 November that 15 security reviews missed the defect; two audits were paid for, in 2022 and 2024.
  • Developers Luke Dashjr and James O'Beirne say they sent warnings to Coinkite before the losses.
  • A firmware update fixes the flaw for new seeds but cannot make an existing seed unpredictable.
  • Trezor found three modified Safe 5 devices sold by CryptoBilis between 20 August and 23 September 2026.

What happened

About 1,800 BTC, worth close to $116M at the exchange rate used, were drained from wallets associated with a defect in Coldcard hardware wallets, according to CryptoActu. The flaw dates to March 2021: the firmware called MicroPython's pseudo-random number generator instead of the hardware source intended in the chip, so seeds presented as unpredictable could be recovered by brute force.

On 9 November, NVK, who leads Coldcard maker Coinkite, said 15 security reviews had missed the defect. Two of those audits were paid for, one for the Mk4 in 2022 and one for the model Q in 2024, CryptoActu reported. An analysis run with an OpenAI tool is said to have flagged 85 potential issues without finding the one that enabled the thefts.

Developers dispute the audit defence

Bitcoin developers contest that reading. Luke Dashjr says he passed nine remarks to Coinkite about the generator's initialisation, errors in the STM32 chips and the detection of repeated values. James O'Beirne says he examined the firmware from May 2025.

Coinkite acknowledges that no full independent audit yet covers every corrected binary. Its security page, updated on 1 October, lists four targeted independent checks. A detailed technical postmortem is still in preparation, according to CryptoActu.

The defect lay in an incomplete check: auditors confirmed the right generator was present in the code but did not confirm that the production firmware actually called it.

What holders are told to do

A software update can fix the path for new seeds. It cannot make a seed created earlier unpredictable. The recommended versions are 5.6.3 for the Mk4 and Mk5 and 1.5.3Q for the model Q.

A seed generated with at least 50 fair dice rolls that were never exposed is treated as providing roughly 128 bits of entropy. Other seeds should be replaced and funds moved to the new addresses after verification, CryptoActu reported.

The article also cites earlier episodes, including a theft of 1,367 BTC and 1,196 addresses in the Coldcard Mk3 case. It says 52.37 BTC have been placed in a trust for victims.

A separate supply-chain case at Trezor

Trezor identified three modified Safe 5 devices sold by CryptoBilis between 20 August and 23 September 2026. A small card hidden between the motherboard and the screen could read displayed information, including the seed, and send it over a mobile network. Trezor says no funds were stolen on those devices.

Firmware 2.13.1, published on 11 November, changes the order of commands sent to the screen to block the capture. Trezor also cut its reseller network by about 80% and advises buyers from CryptoBilis since March 2026 to move funds to a new seed and request a free replacement. No implant has been reported on other models or at other distributors.

Sources

1 report
  1. CryptoActuColdcard : 116 M$ de bitcoins drainés, la controverse

This article was prepared by BattleTown Newsroom from the reports listed above.

Frequently asked questions

Does updating Coldcard firmware make an old seed safe?

No. The update corrects the generator for new seeds but cannot make an already created seed unpredictable. Holders are advised to generate a new seed and move funds to the corresponding addresses.

Which Coldcard firmware versions are recommended?

Version 5.6.3 for the Mk4 and Mk5, and version 1.5.3Q for the model Q, according to CryptoActu.

This story is for information only. It is not financial, investment or legal advice. Disclaimer

Comments: 0 comments

BattleTown: tank battles in the browser

New mini-games, Storm and Breach, are already in BattleTown

Back to the feed

Read also

Type at least 2 characters